Where to Go in the Caribbean: Choosing the Right Island

Choosing where to go in the Caribbean isn’t always as simple as picking the prettiest beach. While turquoise waters and white sand are a given, each island offers a very different experience. Some are ideal for relaxed, all-inclusive escapes, others suit adventurous travellers, and many strike a balance that works well for couples or families.

Whether you’re travelling solo, planning a romantic getaway, celebrating a milestone or heading away with children, knowing what you want from the trip makes all the difference. Below, we explore where to go in the Caribbean based on different travel styles, highlighting islands that suit a variety of travellers.

Barbados

Barbados is one of the most well-rounded Caribbean destinations, blending beautiful beaches with a lively culture and excellent food scene. The west coast is calm and polished, while the south coast offers a more energetic atmosphere with beach bars and water sports.

It’s also one of the more accessible islands, with good infrastructure and a welcoming feel that suits both first-time visitors and repeat travellers.

Ideal for: Couples, solo travellers, families

Antigua

With 365 beaches, Antigua is a favourite for those seeking classic Caribbean relaxation. Calm waters, soft sand and a slower pace make it particularly appealing for couples and honeymooners, while family-friendly resorts provide plenty of activities for children.

Sailing is a major draw here, and the island maintains an elegant, laid-back charm without feeling overdeveloped.

Ideal for: Couples, honeymoons, family holidays

St Lucia

St Lucia stands out for its dramatic scenery, with the iconic Pitons rising above lush rainforests and secluded bays. It’s a popular choice for romantic escapes, offering luxury resorts, private villas and spa experiences set against striking natural backdrops.

Beyond relaxation, St Lucia also appeals to active travellers with hiking, snorkelling and boat trips along the coast.

Ideal for: Couples, honeymooners, adventure-loving travellers

Cayman Islands

The Cayman Islands are known for clear waters, pristine beaches and a refined, low-key atmosphere. Grand Cayman in particular is famous for Seven Mile Beach, excellent snorkelling and diving, and a strong food scene that punches above its size.

The islands feel safe, well organised and relaxed, making them an attractive option for travellers who value quality over crowds. It’s a destination that works equally well for a special occasion or a calm, comfortable holiday.

Ideal for: Couples, celebratory trips

Jamaica

Jamaica offers a vibrant mix of culture, music and natural beauty. From the relaxed beaches of Negril to the waterfalls and mountains around Ocho Rios, there’s plenty of variety within one island.

It’s well suited to travellers who want more than just a resort stay, with excursions, local cuisine and a strong sense of identity adding depth to the experience.

Ideal for: Solo travellers, couples, families with older children

The Bahamas

The Bahamas is made up of over 700 islands and cays, offering everything from lively hubs to quiet, unspoilt escapes. Nassau and Paradise Island are popular for short breaks and family holidays, while the Out Islands provide seclusion and natural beauty.

With easy connections and calm, shallow waters, it’s a strong choice for families and those wanting a straightforward Caribbean escape.

Ideal for: Families, couples, first-time Caribbean visitors

Aruba

Aruba sits outside the main hurricane belt, making it a reliable option year-round. Known for its constant sunshine and breezy climate, the island combines long sandy beaches with a modern, cosmopolitan feel.

It’s particularly appealing to couples and solo travellers who want a mix of relaxation, nightlife and outdoor activities such as windsurfing and snorkelling.

Ideal for: Couples, solo travellers, active holidays

Conclusion: Choosing Where to Go in the Caribbean

When deciding where to go in the Caribbean, it’s important to think about what you want from the trip — whether that’s total relaxation, cultural experiences, adventure or family-friendly facilities. Each island offers a distinct atmosphere, and the right choice depends on who you’re travelling with and the occasion you’re celebrating.

Timing also matters. Many travellers aim for the winter and early spring months, when the weather is at its best and the risk of hurricane season is lower. Planning around these factors will help ensure your Caribbean escape matches your expectations and travel style.